‘Sorry, we screwed up’ – Managing investor reactions with sustainability legitimation strategies
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c9982/c9982cc73a938e86e590ce77ba520f2c3e61b5e0" alt=""
Companies disclosing negative sustainability incidents often employ legitimation strategies to present mishaps in a favorable light. We found that symbolic legitimation, i.e., evasively explaining negative incidents, cannot counter divestments. Only substantial legitimation does, i.e., when a company reports on concrete measures and behavioral changes in morally charged situations.